Revere, Eden, Bird in Hand or Fulton?

We will be spending 3 nights in Lancaster and I can%26#39;t seem to choose between these hotels. We have two children (5 years old) who love to swim.

The rate for the revere is $129 a night for a room with two queens in the main building.

The rate for Eden is $179 a night for 2 queens, or $225 a night for a suite.

Bird in Hand is $143 a night for 2 queens in the pool building.

Fulton is $149 a night for 2 queens.

I am just so confused, is the Eden that much better that it is more expensive? I would like a suite, but not sure it is worth that much more.

Any help would be appreciated.

Revere, Eden, Bird in Hand or Fulton?

Among your choices - Personally I like the Eden. It has a classier feel to it than the other hotels you have listed.

The Fulton - people love this place - I don%26#39;t see it. Reminds me of a cheap Las Vegas motel. Very ornate.

Revere - Its a Best Western. This would probably be my second choice - among your picks.

Bird in Hand - never been there. Sorry can%26#39;t help.

Did you try The Fairfield Inn or Hilton Garden Inn? Both are in Granite Run. I like both of these places. Both are clean, well maintained establishments.

Revere, Eden, Bird in Hand or Fulton?

I%26#39;m only familiar with the Eden %26amp; Bird In Hand. The rooms at the Eden are much nicer in my opinion, they are beautiful. The location is more central to everything (which may or may not be an issue for you, depending on what is on your agenda) and you have easy access to rt 30 and other major routes. Dining options are flexible, with restaurants nearby as well as inside the hotel.

Kids like Bird In Hand better, from my experience. The pools (bigger), the putt putt, etc. The restaurant is decent, but gets VERY crowded. Traffic is a little more congested in that area, too (single-lane). There are things to do within walking distance, unlike the Eden.

If I was choosing between those two, I would pick BIH for travel with kids, or Eden for an adult getaway.

Hope that helps a bit :)

I booked the BIH since this trip is all about the kids!

Thank you both for responding!

good to hear you found the advice you were looking for, hope you have a great time in the area.

p.s. where in Ny are you from I am a born and raised long islander

I love in Westchester County, not too far from LI.

I%26#39;ve only stayed at the Revere in a family suite. Very roomy and clean. Stayed there last year and will be staying there again later this month.